South Africa’s Chief of the South African National Defence Force, General Rudzani Maphwanya, has come under intense criticism after reportedly pledging both military and political support to Iran during a recent visit to the country a move that has sparked political outrage and diplomatic concern.
The trip, which President Cyril Ramaphosa says was not sanctioned by the government, has raised questions about the general’s conduct and the boundaries between military engagements and foreign policy. According to reports, Gen Maphwanya’s remarks in Iran went beyond the scope of standard military-to-military discussions and entered the sensitive realm of foreign relations, a matter strictly reserved for the presidency and the Department of International Relations and Cooperation.
Members of South Africa’s governing coalition, along with the opposition Democratic Alliance (DA), have condemned the general’s actions. The DA has gone as far as calling for him to be court-martialled, describing his statements as “reckless grandstanding” and a direct challenge to South Africa’s official diplomatic stance. Critics say his pledge to Iran could complicate South Africa’s already tense relations with the United States, which has openly expressed concern over Pretoria’s ties with Tehran.
The South African Department of Defence has labelled the remarks “unfortunate”, while presidential spokesperson Vincent Magwenya stressed that the visit was “ill-advised”. Magwenya confirmed that President Ramaphosa was unaware of the trip beforehand and had not given any form of approval for such political commitments to be made.
“The expectation is that the general should have been a lot more circumspect with the comments he makes, particularly in a foreign policy context,” Magwenya told journalists during a briefing on Thursday.
Gen Maphwanya, who travelled to Iran solely for what was meant to be a military engagement, has since returned to South Africa. President Ramaphosa is expected to meet with him to address the incident, which has now become a talking point in both political and diplomatic circles.
The controversy comes at a delicate time for South Africa, as it seeks to balance its foreign policy priorities amid global geopolitical tensions. Analysts warn that such unauthorised and politically sensitive remarks by senior military officials could undermine the country’s international standing and complicate its strategic partnerships.
Leave a comment